Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jonathan Oblak's avatar

I have run with both Apple and Garmin watches, and prefer the Garmin. It's been a couple of years since I ran with an Apple, but battery life was a big issue with the Apple and I really like the different features that Garmin offers and find the Garmin app pretty user friendly. I agree with Conner below that the Apple watch is better for all around Apple integration, but I didn't miss the Apple watch features much when I switched to Garmin. I also recently got a heart rate monitor to pair with the Garmin, because I found that the watch alone was not very accurate for heart rate, which I think is the case for most watch-based monitors. For me, I needed to wear the Garmin watch really tight to get an accurate read on runs. The monitor is much more consistent and I've taken to wearing it most of the time. I also found that some of the other metrics that come with the monitor are interesting, though I'm not quite sure what to do about them. I'm very right foot dominant, which isn't a surprise because I blew out my achilles several years ago. I got into running to try to build that leg back up, and still have some work to do, apparently.

My PR goal right now is a sub-6 minute mile, which at 48 feels fast. I've been marathon training for the last few months, and feel like a focus on shorter distances will be a good change.

Expand full comment
Connor's avatar

In response to the watch question, I've run with both a Garmin Forerunner 245 and an Apple Watch 3. I don't know about the Apple Watch 5 specifically, but the Garmin's ability to program workouts and have it buzz at your to start/finish intervals and keep me on pace by buzzing me too, is really awesome. I also work with a coach who uses the VDOTo2 app and that sync's directly with Garmin so the workouts automatically get sent to my watch. The Apple Watch is way better in terms of usability with Apple products more generally, but the Garmin is the better choice for running.

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts